Comparable Sales Report
Ramona Madeira Cognac Brandy, 'Medicinal Use' Bottle, c.1931
American Medicinal Spirits Company, distilled by Madera Cognac Co., California · Prohibition Era (1920–1933)
The Maker
The production of this bottle represents a fascinating convergence of two distinct entities that defined the survival of the American alcohol industry during the Volstead Act (1920–1933). The spirit itself was distilled by the Madera Cognac Co., the flagship operation of Krikor Arakelian (1871–1951). An Armenian immigrant who became a titan of California viticulture, Arakelian built the Mission Bell Winery into one of the largest operations in the San Joaquin Valley. While many competitors folded during Prohibition, Arakelian survived by legally pivoting to sacramental wines and medicinal brandies, heavily marketing his "Ramona" brand using romanticized imagery of California's mission era.
The bottling and distribution were handled by the American Medicinal Spirits Company (AMS Co.), widely known as the "Whiskey Trust." Formed around 1927 as a subsidiary of National Distillers, AMS Co. was one of only six companies granted federal permits to bottle and sell spirits for medicinal purposes under the Liquor Concentration Act. By 1931, as pre-Prohibition whiskey stocks dwindled, AMS Co. was forced to partner with fruit spirit producers like Arakelian to meet the continuing demand for legal "medicinal" prescriptions.
Valuation
$500 – $800
Insurance / Replacement: $1,500
Auction FMV · 80% confidence
High
A rare and impeccably preserved artifact of the American Prohibition era, this unopened pint of Ramona Madeira Cognac Brandy dates to January 1931. Produced by California viticultural titan Krikor Arakelian and bottled by the "Whiskey Trust" (American Medicinal Spirits Co.), the bottle survives complete with its original wax seal, federal tax stamps, and a handwritten physician's prescription. Prescribed to a Mrs. J. Beach and dispensed by Sunset Drug Co. in Culver City, it stands as a museum-quality example of the "medicinal loophole" that kept the American spirits industry afloat. While vintage brandy does not command the high consumption-driven prices of Prohibition-era bourbons, its exceptional completeness and Hollywood-adjacent provenance elevate its value significantly for collectors of historic Americana.
Market Analysis
The market for Prohibition-era spirits is robust but sharply bifurcated. Tier 1 consists of Kentucky bourbons and ryes (e.g., Old Hermitage, Stitzel-Weller), which are highly sought after by "dusty hunters" intending to consume the liquid, often driving retail prices between $1,400 and $2,000+. Tier 2 encompasses alternative spirits like medicinal brandies, gins, and rums, which are collected primarily as historical artifacts rather than for consumption, as vintage fruit spirits from this era are often oxidized or flat.
Valuation for this Ramona brandy is established by combining its baseline category value with its exceptional ephemera premiums. A comparable unopened California medicinal brandy ("Old Mission") recently sold for approximately $450, establishing a baseline. However, the completeness of this specific package drives the estimate higher. Empty Ramona medicinal bottles have realized $70–$150, while standalone 1930s paper prescriptions fetch $75–$150. Given the pristine preservation of the wax seal, the intact tax stamps, and the highly desirable Culver City (Hollywood-adjacent) retail provenance, this intact artifact commands a "sum of its parts" multiplier, comfortably placing its auction estimate in the $500 to $800 range.
Value Drivers
▲ Exceptional completeness including original wax seal, federal tax strips, and front/back labels.
▲ Intact handwritten 1931 prescription label from Sunset Drug Co. in Culver City, offering highly desirable Los Angeles/Hollywood-adjacent provenance.
▲ Dual-institutional history, showcasing both California viticulture (Arakelian) and the federal 'Whiskey Trust' (AMS Co.).
▲ Physical embodiment of the Volstead Act 'medicinal loophole,' appealing to both spirits collectors and Prohibition historians.
Concerns
▼ California brandy sits in a secondary market compared to the intense demand for Prohibition-era Kentucky bourbons.
▼ The liquid is likely oxidized or 'flat', meaning the bottle has no gustatory value and appeals strictly to display/ephemera collectors.
▼ The 'Ramona' brand was a volume product, lacking the prestige of heritage luxury spirits.
🏛 Best Venue
A specialized vintage spirits auction (e.g., Whisky Auctioneer, Sotheby's Wine & Spirits) or a premier historical Americana/Ephemera sale.
📈 Upside Potential
A bidding war between local Los Angeles historians or Hollywood memorabilia collectors drawn specifically to the Sunset Drug Co./Culver City provenance.
⚠️
Authenticity Notice
Risk Level: Medium. The vintage spirits market has seen an influx of counterfeits, specifically regarding intact tax strips and reproduced labels applied to period-correct glass. The owner must verify that the glass bottle does NOT feature the 'Federal Law Forbids Sale or Re-use of this Bottle' embossing, which was only mandated post-Repeal (1934/1935). The dates on the federal BiB tax strip must also logically precede or align with the January 1931 prescription date. Authentication by a vintage spirits specialist is highly recommended.
Comparable Sales (6)
Sotheby's Wine (Retail/Auction Estimate)
$1,499 USD
Harry E. Wilken AMS Co. Special Old Reserve 1917
MEDIUM
SOLD
"Old Mission" Medicinal Brandy Pint (California), c. 1932
MEDIUM
SOLD
eBay Completed Listing
~$70 - $150 USD
RAMONA Brandy Pre-Pro Bottled In Bond Medicinal Pint (Empty)
MEDIUM
SOLD
Merrill's Auctioneers
Unspecified
Lot of 5 AMS Co. Prohibition Era Whiskey bottles (mixed condition/fill)
MEDIUM
SOLD
1930 Prohibition Whiskey Prescription (Paper only)
MEDIUM
SOLD
Flask Fine Wines (Retail)
$1,795 USD
1916 Old Hermitage Bourbon, Bottled 1927 by AMS Co., Unopened Pint
LOW
LISTED
‹
›
✕
Want a report like this for your own item?
Snap a photo. Get the story, the comps, and the value — free.
Try it free →